3009 McElroy DR, Austin TX 78757

Austin, TX 78757 | Allandale Park

Why It May Not Have Sold

The following is speculative analysis based on publicly available market data. There are many reasons a home may not sell that aren't reflected in MLS data, including personal circumstances, property condition, title issues, or simply a change of plans. This analysis looks only at market positioning factors.

$825,000 Ed's Estimate: $1,292,851 $1,400,000
Lowest Comp Recommended List: $1,267,000 to $1,319,000 Highest Comp

Listing History

$1,300,000 List Price
$1,264,074 Comp Value
0 Price Reductions

This property was listed at $1,300,000 and withdrawn after 36 days on market. This listing activity factors into the valuation.

This home was listed at $1,300,000 and was on the market for 36 days before being withdrawn. Based on comparable sales, the market data suggests a value closer to $1,292,851. Here are some factors that may have played a role: Built in 1967, this home may have faced competition from newer construction in the area priced similarly. At 218 sqft larger than the typical comp, the size difference factors into the valuation. A pool adds market appeal. Only 4 minus 4 of the comps had one. The strength of this estimate comes from 4 directly comparable sales in ALLANDALE PARK. This is strictly a numbers based opinion. Condition, upgrades, and layout can shift value in ways data cannot capture. Have questions? I'm always available. Ed Neuhaus, Neuhaus Realty Group
5 Beds
3 Baths 3 Full
2,876 Sq Ft
0.2364 Acres
1967 Built
2 Garage

About This Property

A true retreat in one of Austin’s most established and central neighborhoods. This spacious and open 2,876 sq ft, single story oasis offers 220 sq ft casita with full bath, saltwater pool, multiple living & dining areas and seamless indoor-outdoor living. Extensive upgrades to the home include plumbing replacement, copper electrical wiring, updated HVAC and ducts, roof, solar, windows, insulation, solar tubes, flooring & custom built-ins. The bright, open kitchen serves as the center of the home with a massive island, custom cabinetry & breakfast nook with vaulted ceiling. The layout flows naturally into the dining & both living rooms, where floor to ceiling windows overlook the exterior and fill the interior with natural light. The casita can function as you please! Separate guest quarters ideal for a nanny, grandparents, visiting family, or long-term guest. Outdoor living is equally as impressive with saltwater pool, a large pergola, concrete patio area & incredible natural edge landscaping. Designed for dining, entertaining, and everyday relaxation, the backyard offers a fantastic extension of the living space. If you feel called to walk, run or bike simply make your way through the front door to and down McElroy to the beautiful, tree shaded, protected pedestrian lanes of legendary Shoal Creek Blvd. Located minutes from Gullett Elementary, Lamar Middle, McCallum High, the shops and restaurants along Burnet Road, this home delivers walkability, convenience, and an exceptional Central Austin lifestyle.

Property Highlights

Pool In Ground, Outdoor Pool, Saltwater

Features

  • Bookcases
  • Breakfast Bar
  • Built-in Features
  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Beamed Ceilings
  • Granite Counters
  • Entrance Foyer
  • In-Law Floorplan
  • Kitchen Island
  • Multiple Living Areas
  • No Interior Steps
  • Primary Bedroom on Main
  • Solar Tube(s)
  • Walk-In Closet(s)

Location

Schools

School District Austin ISD
Elementary Gullett
Middle School Lamar (Austin ISD)
High School McCallum

Property Details

Property Type Residential
Flooring Carpet, Tile, Vinyl, Wood
Cooling Central Air
Heating Central, Natural Gas, Solar
Exterior Dog Run, Private Yard
County Travis
MLS # 1057933

Parking

Garage 2 spaces

Tax Information

Annual Taxes $12,957 (2025)

Listing History

MLS# 1057933 36 days
May 1, 2026 Off Market
Mar 26, 2026 Listed $1,300,000

Frequently Asked Questions About 3009 McElroy DR, Austin TX 78757

When was 3009 McElroy DR, Austin TX 78757 built?

3009 McElroy DR, Austin TX 78757 was built in 1967.

How much does 3009 McElroy DR, Austin TX 78757 cost?

3009 McElroy DR, Austin TX 78757 is currently off market.

Similar Properties

Browse More Properties

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.