437 Stagecoach DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133

Canyon Lake, TX 78133 | Canyon Lake Hills

Off Market

Exterior view of 437 Stagecoach DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133

Additional photos available to registered users

Ed's Opinion of Value

$353,572 Ed's Estimate: $441,811 $701,826

Lowest Comp Recommended List: $483,000 to $508,000 Highest Comp

The comparable sales data (7 recent transactions in 78133) supports an estimated value of $441,811. The data suggests a list price between $483,000 and $508,000 would attract qualified buyers without leaving money on the table. Relative to what's currently available in 78133, this home would be the 3rd least expensive of 7 comparable homes on the market. Being built in 1989 (14 years older than comps) is factored into the value estimate. Lot size matters here: 0.21 acres versus 0.56 for the typical comp. Buyers in 78133 have 7 comparable options right now, with asking prices between $399,000 and $675,000. Prices in 78133 have fallen 16.9% over the last 6 months. A similar home at 149 Gallagher DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 carries an adjusted comparable value of $362,964, providing a strong data point. The strength of this estimate comes from 7 directly comparable sales in 78133. This is strictly a numbers based opinion. Condition, upgrades, and layout can shift value in ways data cannot capture. Have questions? I'm always available. Ed Neuhaus, Neuhaus Realty Group

78133 Market Trends

$374,922 Median Sold Price ▼ 16.9% 6mo

$225/sqft Median $/SqFt ▼ 2.4% 6mo

119 days Avg Days on Market 15 days slower

82 homes Active Inventory 12.9 mo supply

96.7% Sale-to-List Ratio

38 Sales (6 months)

Recently Sold Comparables

$362,964 adjusted 149 Gallagher DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 5bd / 3.0ba • 2,328 sqft • 1.7 mi Sold 2 months ago

$353,572 adjusted 1530 Trailridge DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,288 sqft • 1.1 mi Sold 3 months ago

$395,804 adjusted 307 Lorne RD, Canyon Lake TX 78133 4bd / 3.0ba • 2,400 sqft • 2.1 mi Sold 8 months ago

$483,192 adjusted 309 Watts LN, Canyon Lake TX 78133 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,061 sqft • 1.8 mi Sold 8 months ago

$701,826 adjusted 131 Cedar Tree LN, Canyon Lake TX 78133 4bd / 5.0ba • 2,550 sqft • 0.5 mi Sold 7 months ago

Currently on Market

$399,000 2720 Westview DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,386 sqft • 1 mi 45 days on market

$499,900 773 Lookout DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 3bd / 2.0ba • 2,460 sqft • 0.5 mi 180 days on market

$429,000 1156 Riviera DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,244 sqft • 0.2 mi 58 days on market

4 Beds

3 Baths 3 Full

2,359 Sq Ft

0.2052 Acres

1989 Built

2 Garage

About This Property

THIS IS A SHOW STOPPER! You'll fall in love with this beautifully maintained lake house, just 1 street off the water's edge at Canyon Lake. The owners have upgraded this home beyond belief, with a Smart door at the front with privacy glass at the touch of a button, new cable railing at the front deck, a greenhouse, RV parking with 30AMP hookup, storage building, outdoor kitchen, hot tub, playscape, chicken coop, and so much more. See the Special Features page in the additional documents tab. Even the landscaping incorporates a butterfly/pollinator garden, and Fruit trees (peach, pear, lemon, and a grapevine). Inside, you'll find updates throughout such as lighting, flooring, bathrooms, and the light and bright kitchen. The high ceilings, accented with soaring windows are anchored by the corner fireplace. Special effect lighting is controlled through an app on your phone. To see is to believe!

Features

Ceiling Fan(s)
Cathedral Ceiling(s)
High Ceilings
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Chandelier
Granite Counters
Electric Dryer Hookup
Entrance Foyer
French Doors
High Speed Internet
Interior Steps
Multiple Living Areas
Open Floorplan
Storage
Walk-In Closet(s)
Washer Hookup

Location

Map loading...

Schools

School District Comal ISD

Elementary Startzville

Middle School Mountain Valley Middle

High School Canyon Lake

Property Details

Property Type Residential

Flooring Carpet, Laminate

Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air, Electric

Heating Central, Electric, Fireplace(s)

Exterior Balcony, Boat Ramp, Outdoor Grill, Playground

County Comal

MLS # 7024675

Parking

Garage 2 spaces

HOA & Community

HOA Fee $24 /Annually

HOA Includes Common Area Maintenance

Tax Information

Annual Taxes $4,458 (2024)

Listing History

MLS# 7024675 - Updated Mar 23, 2026 174 days

Aug 13, 2025	Off Market
Feb 20, 2025	Listed		$567,000

Frequently Asked Questions About 437 Stagecoach DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133

When was 437 Stagecoach DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 built?

437 Stagecoach DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 was built in 1989.

How much does 437 Stagecoach DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 cost?

437 Stagecoach DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 sold on August 13, 2025. Contact us for sale price details.

Similar Properties

$489,999 35 Presidio RD, Wimberley TX 78676 4 bd | 3 ba

$449,000 1871 Patty DR, Canyon Lake TX 78133 4 bd | 3 ba

$465,000 1624 Stone House DR, New Braunfels TX 78132 4 bd | 4 ba

$489,000 3217 32, San Marcos TX 78666 3 bd | 3 ba

Browse More Properties

4-Bedroom Homes in Canyon Lake Homes $500K-$750K in Canyon Lake All Homes for Sale in Canyon Lake Homes in 78133 Homes in Comal County Homes in Comal ISD All 4-Bedroom Homes Homes for Rent Land for Sale

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

Your Name *

Email Address *

Phone Number *

Message *

Are you currently working with an agent? *

I'd like to schedule a tour

I am pre-qualified for financing

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.