168 Potato Smith RD, Elgin TX 78621

Elgin, TX 78621 | Goodwin, William

Why It May Not Have Sold

The following is speculative analysis based on publicly available market data. There are many reasons a home may not sell that aren't reflected in MLS data, including personal circumstances, property condition, title issues, or simply a change of plans. This analysis looks only at market positioning factors.

$310,845 Ed's Estimate: $421,193 $1,500,000
Lowest Comp Recommended List: $413,000 to $430,000 Highest Comp

Listing History

$775,000 List Price
$400,601 Comp Value
0 Price Reductions

This property was listed at $775,000 and expired after 3 days on market. This listing activity factors into the valuation.

This home was listed at $775,000 and was on the market for 3 days before expiring. Based on comparable sales, the market data suggests a value closer to $421,193. Here are some factors that may have played a role: At $262/sqft, the asking price appears to have been significantly above the neighborhood average of $161/sqft. That gap that can deter buyer interest. At $262/sqft, the asking price was 63% above the area median, though there may have been upgrades or features not captured in the data. Built in 1958, this home may have faced competition from newer construction in the area priced similarly. The larger floor plan (945 sqft compared to the average comp) is a meaningful differentiator in this price range. At 31 years older than typical comps, the 1958 build date influences the valuation. With 7 comparable sales in GOODWIN, WILLIAM, this estimate carries a reasonable degree of confidence. This estimate is based entirely on market data. An in person evaluation could refine it further. Ed Neuhaus, Broker/Owner, Neuhaus Realty Group
4 Beds
2 Baths 2 Full
2,959 Sq Ft
16.042 Acres
1958 Built

About This Property

Discover the perfect blend of country living and equestrian functionality on this unrestricted 16+ acre property, located less than an hour from Austin. Designed with horse enthusiasts in mind, the property features an impressive 8,400 sq. ft covered arena complete with 6 stalls, tack room, lighting, and five pole barns—offering everything you need for training, boarding, or livestock operations. The charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath farmhouse combines character and updates, with the original structure built in 1958 and a second story added in 2002. Enjoy peaceful evenings from the wraparound covered wooden deck, surrounded by mature oak trees and scenic countryside views. A versatile 576 sq ft detached building with water and electricity previously used as an aviary offers endless possibilities as a workshop, office, or studio. What truly sets this property apart is the infrastructure already in place: 3 water meters (Aqua Water), 3 electric meters (Bluebonnet Electric), Multiple septic systems, including one on a separate fenced 1-acre homesite. The additional fenced acre, shaded by beautiful oaks, is ready for another home, making this an excellent opportunity for multi-generational living, rental income, or expansion. With no restrictions and abundant space, this property offers unmatched flexibility to create your ideal rural lifestyle.

Property Highlights

View Panoramic, Pasture, Rural

Features

  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Beamed Ceilings
  • Laminate Counters
  • Tile Counters
  • Double Vanity
  • Electric Dryer Hookup
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • French Doors
  • Pantry
  • Storage
  • Washer Hookup
  • See Remarks

Location

Schools

School District McDade ISD
Elementary McDade
Middle School McDade
High School Elgin

Property Details

Property Type Residential
Construction HardiPlank Type
Roof Metal
Foundation Pillar/Post/Pier, See Remarks
Levels Two
Flooring Carpet, Tile, Vinyl
Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air, Electric
Heating Propane, Space Heater, See Remarks
Exterior Balcony, Gutters Partial, See Remarks
County Bastrop
MLS # 3298737
Parking 10 spaces: Carport, Outside, Unpaved
Windows Double Pane Windows, Screens

Lot, Outdoor & Utilities

Lot Features Back Yard, Farm, Open Lot, Trees-Large (Over 40 Ft), Trees-Medium (20 Ft - 40 Ft)
Patio & Porch Covered, Deck, Porch, Rear Porch, Side Porch
Fencing Chain Link, Cross Fenced, Livestock, Perimeter
Other Structures Barn(s), Covered Arena, Storage
Water Public
Sewer Septic Tank
Utilities Above Ground, Electricity Connected, Phone Available, Water Connected

HOA & Community

Community Features None

Tax Information

Annual Taxes (MLS) $6,817 (2025)
Assessed Value $430,302
Exemptions Homestead, Over 65

Listing History

MLS# 3298737 3 days
Apr 19, 2026 Off Market
Apr 16, 2026 Listed $775,000

Frequently Asked Questions About 168 Potato Smith RD, Elgin TX 78621

When was 168 Potato Smith RD, Elgin TX 78621 built?

168 Potato Smith RD, Elgin TX 78621 was built in 1958. It is hardiplank type construction with 2,959 square feet on a 16.042 acre lot.

How much does 168 Potato Smith RD, Elgin TX 78621 cost?

168 Potato Smith RD, Elgin TX 78621 is currently off market.

Similar Properties

Browse More Properties

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.