125 Mitchell Creek DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657

Horseshoe Bay, TX 78657 | Siena Creek Ph One

Contact Us
Off Market
Exterior view of 125 Mitchell Creek DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
Additional photos available to registered users

Ed's Opinion of Value

$604,800 Ed's Estimate: $820,470 $1,935,138
Lowest Comp Recommended List: $1,148,000 to $1,210,000 Highest Comp

Listing History

$749,000 List Price
$1,225,464 Comp Value
0 Price Reductions

This property was listed at $749,000 and expired after 23 days on market. This listing activity factors into the valuation.

Ed Neuhaus
Looking at what buyers have actually paid for similar homes nearby, this property comes in at approximately $820,470. To generate strong buyer interest while maximizing value, I'd price this between $1,148,000 and $1,210,000. With 7 comparable homes on the market in SIENA CREEK PH ONE, this price positions the property as the 3rd least expensive of 7 comparable homes on the market. The larger floor plan (336 sqft compared to the average comp) is a meaningful differentiator in this price range. At 0.85 acres, the lot is larger than the 0.33 acre comp average, which factors into pricing. 7 comparable transactions in SIENA CREEK PH ONE support the reliability of this estimate. As always, a data based estimate has its limits. Seeing the home in person is the best way to confirm value. Ed Neuhaus, Broker/Owner | Neuhaus Realty Group

78657 Market Trends

$690,000 Median Sold Price ▼ 3.6% 6mo
$335/sqft Median $/SqFt ▲ 7.4% 6mo
153 days Avg Days on Market 50 days slower
186 homes Active Inventory 16.2 mo supply
95.1% Sale-to-List Ratio
69 Sales (6 months)

Recently Sold Comparables

116 Blister Gold, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$1,018,225 adjusted 116 Blister Gold, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 4.0ba • 3,083 sqft • 0.4 mi Sold 10 months ago
105 Bent One, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$1,602,025 adjusted 105 Bent One, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 4bd / 3.0ba • 3,306 sqft • 1.6 mi Sold 9 months ago
102 Maravilla WAY, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$604,800 adjusted 102 Maravilla WAY, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 3.0ba • 1,995 sqft • 0.1 mi Sold 5 months ago
100 Bowers CIR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$1,935,138 adjusted 100 Bowers CIR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 4.0ba • 2,825 sqft • 0.4 mi Sold 1 months ago
305 Blue Ground, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$1,209,613 adjusted 305 Blue Ground, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 4.0ba • 3,450 sqft • 0.6 mi Sold 9 months ago

Currently on Market

418 The Hills RD, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$999,000 418 The Hills RD, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 3.0ba • 3,118 sqft • 2.1 mi 330 days on market
600 Mountain Dew RD, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$795,000 600 Mountain Dew RD, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,952 sqft • 2.6 mi 81 days on market
3305 Close Call, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$895,000 3305 Close Call, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 4.0ba • 2,853 sqft • 1.7 mi 1 days on market
3 Beds
3 Baths 3 Full
3,200 Sq Ft
0.85 Acres
2006 Built
3 Garage

About This Property

This Custom Home in Siena Creek, a gated private community in the heart of Horseshoe Bay, sits on .85ac w/beautiful trees & tranquil views of Pecan Creek. Single level living with a large living area, dining, butler's pantry, breakfast area, kitchen w/granite, gas range & all the extras plus a spacious 3 car garage. Spectacular backyard faces east with large trees, grassy areas, outdoor fireplace & room for a pool. Original owners, immaculate and move in ready. Ask about Special The Club @HSBay incentives

Features

  • Bookcases
  • Breakfast Bar
  • Coffered Ceiling(s)
  • High Ceilings
  • Crown Molding
  • Entrance Foyer
  • Pantry
  • Primary Bedroom on Main
  • Recessed Lighting
  • Walk-In Closet(s)

Location

Map loading...

Schools

School District Llano ISD
Elementary Llano
Middle School Llano
High School Llano

Property Details

Property Type Residential
Flooring Carpet, Stone
Cooling Central Air
Heating Central, Electric
Exterior Boat Ramp, Gutters Full
County Llano
MLS # 5220608

Parking

Garage 3 spaces

HOA & Community

HOA Fee $1,915 /Annually
HOA Includes Common Area Maintenance, Insurance

Tax Information

Annual Taxes $7,019 (2019)

Listing History

MLS# 5220608 - Updated Mar 22, 2026 23 days (304 CDOM)
Dec 31, 2020 Off Market
Dec 1, 2020 Listed $749,000

Frequently Asked Questions About 125 Mitchell Creek DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657

When was 125 Mitchell Creek DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 built?

125 Mitchell Creek DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 was built in 2006.

How much does 125 Mitchell Creek DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 cost?

125 Mitchell Creek DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 is currently off market.

Similar Properties

104 Mason Court, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$675,000 104 Mason Court, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3 bd | 3 ba
101 Blanco CT, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$615,000 101 Blanco CT, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3 bd | 3 ba
109 Lost SPUR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657
$615,000 109 Lost SPUR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3 bd | 3 ba
530 County Road 123A RD # 123A, Marble Falls TX 78654
$669,000 530 County Road 123A RD # 123A, Marble Falls TX 78654 3 bd | 3 ba

Browse More Properties

3-Bedroom Homes in Horseshoe Bay Homes $500K-$750K in Horseshoe Bay All Homes for Sale in Horseshoe Bay Homes in 78657 Homes in Llano County Homes in Llano ISD All 3-Bedroom Homes Homes for Rent Land for Sale
Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.

Take a look at our sister companies

StaySTRA Bizzy Lizzy Boutique Kendall Creek Properties

Listings courtesy of ACTRIS as distributed by MLS GRID. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 Austin Central Texas Realty Information Service. Full MLS Disclaimer