609 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657

Horseshoe Bay, TX 78657 | Horseshoe Bay Proper

Off Market

View of subject property with a heavily wooded area

Additional photos available to registered users

Ed's Opinion of Value

$338,735 Ed's Estimate: $684,143 $1,035,813

Lowest Comp Recommended List: $670,000 to $698,000 Highest Comp

The market data from 6 similar recent sales in HORSESHOE BAY PROPER points to a value of approximately $684,143. To sell within a reasonable timeframe at fair market value, the $670,000 to $698,000 range is where I'd position this. With 7 comparable homes on the market in HORSESHOE BAY PROPER, this price positions the property as the 3rd least expensive of 7 comparable homes on the market. The 186 sqft size difference versus comparable sales is reflected in the adjusted values. At 0.31 acres, the lot is larger than the 0.25 acre comp average, which factors into pricing. 7 similar homes are currently available in HORSESHOE BAY PROPER, creating a buyer's market for this price range. In HORSESHOE BAY PROPER, home values have fallen approximately 1.2% over the past 6 months. One of the strongest data points is 624 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657, adjusting to $639,528; with a smaller floor plan. The 6 comps used here provide a solid foundation for this valuation. Keep in mind, I have not personally inspected this property. The numbers are data driven, not firsthand. Questions about this property or this area? Reach out anytime. Ed Neuhaus, Neuhaus Realty Group

HORSESHOE BAY PROPER Market Trends

$580,000 Median Sold Price ▼ 1.2% 6mo

$218/sqft Median $/SqFt ▼ 11% 6mo

97 days Avg Days on Market 31 days faster

16 homes Active Inventory 4.2 mo supply

93.0% Sale-to-List Ratio

23 Sales (6 months)

$1,073,645 Tax Assessed (2025)

Recently Sold Comparables

$639,528 adjusted 624 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 4.0ba • 3,068 sqft • 0.1 mi Sold 1 months ago

$1,035,813 adjusted 1200 Thataway, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 4.0ba • 2,972 sqft • 0.5 mi Sold 4 months ago

$690,518 adjusted 715 Fawn, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 4bd / 4.0ba • 3,168 sqft • 0.5 mi Sold 1 months ago

$338,735 adjusted 808 Ox Bow, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 4bd / 4.0ba • 3,169 sqft • 0.4 mi Sold 1 months ago

$767,620 adjusted 800 Western Bit, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,888 sqft • 0.5 mi Sold 4 months ago

Currently on Market

$592,410 100 Semi CIR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 5bd / 4.0ba • 3,255 sqft • 0.3 mi 151 days on market

$509,000 634 Broken HLS, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 4.0ba • 2,775 sqft • 3 mi 54 days on market

$849,900 604 Hi Circle South DR, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,726 sqft • 0.1 mi 126 days on market

3 Beds

4 Baths 3 Full, 1 Half

3,204 Sq Ft

0.3139 Acres

1983 Built

2 Garage

About This Property

View Virtual Tour

In the Heart of Horseshoe Bay: an Architectural Gem sitting on Slickrock signature hole #14. This home offers a combination of modern & traditional comforts with stunning views! Significant structural, material & equipment upgrades throughout the home: high-end luxury flooring, custom kitchen cabinets, appliances, granite, center island, Great Room vaulted 14' ceiling with beams, stone fireplace, stonewall with large built-in Tv & wet bar, 6 panel solid oak doors throughout, new showers with modern tile, counters, plumbing & lighting fixtures, 5 Ton HVAC, water heater, and washer/dryer. 2020 Standing Seam Roof with high-efficient foam attic insulation. Great floorplan includes 3 bedroom ensuites! Large Master bedroom with his/her closets, Master bath features: dual vanity, walk-in shower, private jetted whirlpool tub & TV. Wonderful Den/Media room with new floor-to-ceiling windows, pool table, electric fireplace & TV. Wrap-around covered patio includes beautiful oak ceilings, drop lighting, a built-in grill, TV & slab/firepit all with incredible golf course & hill country views! 2-car garage with golf cart storage & a room for fitness equipment or extra storage! New aluminum ladder drop-down for attic access. If you're looking for a unique home in the Horseshoe Bay community, come see this special home! Home is furnished with few exceptions!

Property Highlights

View Golf Course, Hill Country

Features

Bookcases
Ceiling Fan(s)
Beamed Ceilings
High Ceilings
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Double Vanity
Electric Dryer Hookup
Entrance Foyer
High Speed Internet
Kitchen Island
Pantry
Primary Bedroom on Main
Recessed Lighting
Sound System
Storage
Walk-In Closet(s)
Wet Bar
Wired for Sound

Location

Map loading...

Schools

School District Llano ISD

Elementary Packsaddle

Middle School Llano

High School Llano

Property Details

Property Type Residential

Construction Stone, See Remarks

Roof Metal

Foundation Slab

Levels One

Flooring Carpet, Tile

Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air, Electric

Heating Central, Electric, Exhaust Fan, Fireplace(s), Heat Pump

Fireplace Den, Electric, Living Room, Masonry, Stone

Exterior Gas Grill, Lighting, Outdoor Grill, Private Yard, Satellite Dish Leased

County Llano

MLS # 9887760

Garage 2 spaces

Parking 8 spaces: Additional Parking, Circular Driveway, Driveway, Garage, Garage Door Opener, Garage Faces Side, Golf Cart Garage

Windows Drapes, Double Pane Windows, Screens, Tinted Windows, Wood Frames

Security Smoke Detector(s)

Lot, Outdoor & Utilities

Lot Features Back Yard, Cleared, Few Trees, Front Yard, Landscaped, Level, Near Golf Course, Public Maintained Road, Sprinkler - Automatic, Sprinkler - Back Yard, Sprinklers In Front, Sprinkler - In-ground, Sprinkler - Side Yard, Trees-Medium (20 Ft - 40 Ft), Trees-Moderate, Views

Patio & Porch Covered, Front Porch, Patio, Wrap Around

Water Public

Sewer Public Sewer

Utilities Cable Available, Electricity Connected, Other, Natural Gas Not Available, Phone Available, Sewer Connected, Underground Utilities, Water Connected

HOA & Community

HOA Fee $361 /Annually

HOA Name Horseshoe Bay Property Owners Association

HOA Includes See Remarks

Community Features Clubhouse, Cluster Mailbox, Conference/Meeting Room, Fishing, Fitness Center, Golf, High Speed Internet, Lake, Mini-Golf, Park, Planned Social Activities, Playground, Pool, Putting Green, Restaurant, Sport Court(s)/Facility, Tennis Court(s), Trash Pickup - Door to Door, Underground Utilities

Tax Information

Annual Taxes (MLS) $14,368 (2025)

Assessed Value $1,073,645

Exemptions None

Listing History

MLS# 9887760 37 days

Apr 30, 2026	Off Market
Apr 16, 2026	Pending
Mar 10, 2026	Listed	$945,000

MLS# 5244506 263 days

Nov 30, 2025	Off Market
Mar 12, 2025	Listed		$975,000

MLS# 3882597 43 days

Sep 15, 2023	Off Market
Jun 29, 2023	Listed		$995,000

MLS# 7762584 84 days

Dec 12, 2022	Off Market
Sep 19, 2022	Listed		$995,000

MLS# 2779577 223 days

Mar 23, 2017	Off Market
May 14, 2016	Listed		$349,000

Frequently Asked Questions About 609 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657

When was 609 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 built?

609 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 was built in 1983. It is stone, see remarks construction with 3,204 square feet on a 0.3139 acre lot.

How much does 609 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 cost?

609 Hi Stirrup, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 sold on April 30, 2026. Contact us for sale price details.

Similar Properties

$775,000 221 County Road 136C, Kingsland TX 78639 3 bd | 4 ba

$699,000 101 Belforte BLVD, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3 bd | 4 ba

$725,000 402 Lost Echo # 4, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3 bd | 4 ba

$749,000 101 Fox Fur, Horseshoe Bay TX 78657 3 bd | 4 ba

Browse More Properties

3-Bedroom Homes in Horseshoe Bay Homes $750K-$1M in Horseshoe Bay All Homes for Sale in Horseshoe Bay Homes in 78657 Homes in Llano County Homes in Llano ISD All 3-Bedroom Homes Homes for Rent Land for Sale

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

Your Name *

Email Address *

Phone Number *

Message *

Are you currently working with an agent? *

I'd like to schedule a tour

I am pre-qualified for financing

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.