350 McGarity, Kyle TX 78640

Kyle, TX 78640 | Plum Creek

Ed's Opinion of Value

$437,751 Ed's Estimate: $485,101 $679,900
Lowest Comp Recommended List: $514,000 to $536,000 Highest Comp
5 recent sales within half a mile of this address suggest a current value of $485,101. My recommended list price range for this property would be $514,000 to $536,000. Among the similar homes currently available in PLUM CREEK, this price point stands out as competitive. The larger floor plan (549 sqft compared to the average comp) is a meaningful differentiator in this price range. The 0.21 acre lot (larger than the 0.18 acre average) is reflected in the estimate. Right now, 5 similar properties are competing for buyers in PLUM CREEK, listed between $449,900 and $679,900. In PLUM CREEK, home values have fallen approximately 4.4% over the past 6 months. One of the strongest data points is 134 Caraway, Kyle TX 78640, adjusting to $497,472; with a smaller floor plan. With 5 solid comps to draw from, the data tells a consistent story. Of course, without seeing the property in person, this is a data based estimate only. Ed Neuhaus, Neuhaus Realty Group
5 Beds
3 Baths 3 Full
3,310 Sq Ft
0.2111 Acres
2006 Built
2 Garage

About This Property

Large Plum Creek home backing to the golf course, in the process of a complete and very thoughtful renovation by the owner. No detail has been overlooked: Full interior paint, new flooring downstairs, new W/D/F installed. All hardware has been replaced with dark oil-rubbed bronze, even handles and hinges! New light fixtures, toilets, and even sink and storage in the laundry room have been added. All vent covers, outlet covers, switch plates, blinds, etc. have been removed, cleaned, and/or replaced. This is not a "flip" - it's a thoughtful reimagining that brings it on par with new construction. Five generously-sized bedrooms total - the primary and three others upstairs and a 5th bedroom and 3rd full bath downstairs. Downstairs bedroom could be used as guest quarters, office, yoga studio, or even a "man cave"! Game room upstairs with windows looking out at the treetops. The kitchen features fresh white cabinetry, built-in appliances, and a large center island that doubles as a serving bar. A gas fireplace warms the main living space, and a wall of windows provide calming views of the oversized back yard and golf course beyond. Watch the Kyle fireworks from the deck balcony or lounge on the grass below!
McGarity is the Halloween/Christmas hotspot of Plum Creek and one of the most coveted streets. Tenants will have access to the neighborhood pools, playgrounds, picnic areas, dog park, pickleball and basketball courts, trails, catch-and-release fishing, and more.
Zoned for the *highly* sought Negley Elementary, Barton MS, and Hays HS. Negley is just down the street and many families walk to/from school and chat along the way.
This is your chance to move in and see why Plum Creek is Kyle's most adored neighborhood!

Features

  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • Granite Counters
  • Double Vanity
  • Interior Steps
  • Kitchen Island
  • Multiple Dining Areas
  • Multiple Living Areas
  • Open Floorplan
  • Pantry
  • Soaking Tub
  • Storage
  • Walk-In Closet(s)

Location

Schools

School District Hays CISD
Elementary Laura B Negley
Middle School R C Barton
High School Jack C Hays

Property Details

Property Type Residential Lease
Flooring Carpet, Tile, Vinyl
Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air
Exterior Balcony
County Hays
MLS # 2413843

Parking

Garage 2 spaces

Listing History

MLS# 2413843 23 days
Jul 15, 2025 Off Market
Jun 22, 2025 Listed $2,900

Frequently Asked Questions About 350 McGarity, Kyle TX 78640

When was 350 McGarity, Kyle TX 78640 built?

350 McGarity, Kyle TX 78640 was built in 2006.

How much does 350 McGarity, Kyle TX 78640 cost?

350 McGarity, Kyle TX 78640 sold on July 15, 2025. Contact us for sale price details.

Similar Properties

Browse More Properties

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.