5740 Mcnaughton, Kyle TX 78640

Kyle, TX 78640 | Plum Creek | Built by Horton

Off Market

Exterior view of 5740 Mcnaughton, Kyle TX 78640

Additional photos available to registered users

Ed's Opinion of Value

$286,200 Ed's Estimate: $323,601 $359,990

Lowest Comp Recommended List: $338,000 to $346,000 Highest Comp

Based on what similar homes have actually sold for within half a mile, I'd place this property's value at $323,601. I'd recommend coming to market at $338,000 to $346,000 to strike the right balance between value and market velocity. Among the similar homes currently available in PLUM CREEK, this price point stands out as competitive. Buyers in PLUM CREEK have 3 comparable options right now, with asking prices between $286,200 and $359,990. The trend in PLUM CREEK shows prices have fallen 5.9% in the past 6 months. 166 Caraway, Kyle TX 78640 nearby adjusts to $304,684; a strong comparable. Based on 7 relevant data points in PLUM CREEK, I'm comfortable with this estimate. Without stepping inside, I can only go by what the data shows. An in person look would tell the full story. Ed Neuhaus, Neuhaus Realty Group | Austin, TX

PLUM CREEK Market Trends

$300,000 Median Sold Price ▼ 5.9% 6mo

$174/sqft Median $/SqFt ▼ 6.5% 6mo

74 days Avg Days on Market 39 days slower

31 homes Active Inventory 8.1 mo supply

98.1% Sale-to-List Ratio

23 Sales (6 months)

Recently Sold Comparables

$304,684 adjusted 166 Caraway, Kyle TX 78640 3bd / 2.0ba • 1,941 sqft • 0.7 mi Sold 3 months ago

$313,546 adjusted 4905 HARTSON, Kyle TX 78640 4bd / 3.0ba • 2,123 sqft • 0.7 mi Sold 4 months ago

$289,525 adjusted 420 Hogan, Kyle TX 78640 3bd / 3.0ba • 2,093 sqft • 0.5 mi Sold 3 months ago

$321,317 adjusted 231 Skinner, Kyle TX 78640 3bd / 2.0ba • 1,941 sqft • 0.7 mi Sold 1 months ago

$346,120 adjusted 5781 Fergus, Kyle TX 78640 3bd / 2.0ba • 1,831 sqft • 0.6 mi Sold 8 months ago

Currently on Market

$359,990 334 Haupt DR, Kyle TX 78640 4bd / 3.0ba • 1,824 sqft • 0.4 mi 19 days on market

$286,200 201 Caraway DR, Kyle TX 78640 4bd / 2.0ba • 2,088 sqft • 0.7 mi 77 days on market

$337,000 1048 Sanders, Kyle TX 78640 3bd / 2.0ba • 2,084 sqft • 1.3 mi 2 days on market

4 Beds

3 Baths 2 Full, 1 Half

1,938 Sq Ft

0.176 Acres

2001 Built

2 Garage

About This Property

YOUR BEST MEMORIES WILL BE AT THIS HOME! This MUST SEE Plum Creek home is perfectly positioned on an oversized corner lot. The open and functional floor-plan is better than new, featuring recently updated granite counters, wood-look tile flooring, fresh paint, re-finished fireplace and designer fixtures. New roof in 2016. Large backyard and private patio are perfect for entertaining!Restrictions: Yes Sprinkler Sys:Yes

Features

High Ceilings
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Interior Steps
Pantry
Walk-In Closet(s)

Location

Map loading...

Schools

School District Hays ISD

Elementary Laura B Negley

Middle School R C Barton

High School Jack C Hays

Property Details

Property Type Residential

Flooring Carpet, Tile

Cooling Central Air

Heating Natural Gas

Exterior Balcony, Exterior Steps

County Hays

MLS # 9405819

Parking

Garage 2 spaces

HOA & Community

HOA Fee $134 /Quarterly

HOA Includes Common Area Maintenance

Listing History

MLS# 9405819 - Updated Mar 13, 2026 3 days

Apr 5, 2019	Off Market
Feb 25, 2019	Pending
Feb 22, 2019	Listed	$250,000

MLS# 3353739 103 days

Oct 20, 2016	Off Market
Jul 9, 2016	Listed		$230,000

MLS# 8542860 1 days

Mar 31, 2009	Off Market
Feb 28, 2009	Listed		$164,900

Frequently Asked Questions About 5740 Mcnaughton, Kyle TX 78640

When was 5740 Mcnaughton, Kyle TX 78640 built?

5740 Mcnaughton, Kyle TX 78640 was built in 2001.

How much does 5740 Mcnaughton, Kyle TX 78640 cost?

5740 Mcnaughton, Kyle TX 78640 sold on April 5, 2019. Contact us for sale price details.

Similar Properties

$199,900 157 Pebble Creek LN, Buda TX 78610 4 bd | 3 ba

$214,490 134 Meuse LN, Kyle TX 78640 3 bd | 3 ba

$216,490 191 Pink Footed PASS, Uhland TX 78640 4 bd | 2 ba

$218,990 205 E Lima DR, Maxwell TX 78656 4 bd | 2 ba

Browse More Properties

4-Bedroom Homes in Kyle Homes under $300K in Kyle All Homes for Sale in Kyle Homes in 78640 Homes in Hays County Homes in Hays ISD All 4-Bedroom Homes Homes for Rent Land for Sale

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

Your Name *

Email Address *

Phone Number *

Message *

Are you currently working with an agent? *

I'd like to schedule a tour

I am pre-qualified for financing

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.