258 N Water ST, La Grange TX 78945

Off Market

White stucco exterior featuring a covered porch with wood railing, dark entry door, and metal roofing

Additional photos available to registered users

Why It May Not Have Sold

The following is speculative analysis based on publicly available market data. There are many reasons a home may not sell that aren't reflected in MLS data, including personal circumstances, property condition, title issues, or simply a change of plans. This analysis looks only at market positioning factors.

$169,000 Ed's Estimate: $260,512 $260,512

Lowest Comp Recommended List: $255,000 to $266,000 Highest Comp

Listing History

$270,000 List Price

$225,457 Comp Value

0 Price Reductions

This property was listed at $270,000 and expired after 146 days on market. This listing activity factors into the valuation.

This home was listed at $270,000 and was on the market for 146 days before expiring. Based on comparable sales, the market data suggests a value closer to $260,512. Here are some factors that may have played a role: After 146 days on market, buyer interest typically drops, and listings can become "stale" in buyer perception. At $276/sqft, the asking price was 52% above the area median, though there may have been upgrades or features not captured in the data. Built in 1950, this home may have faced competition from newer construction in the area priced similarly. This home's smaller footprint (586 sqft vs the comp average) plays a role in how the market prices it. At 0.35 acres, the lot is larger than the 0.31 acre comp average, which factors into pricing. The 7 comps used here provide a solid foundation for this valuation. Keep in mind, I have not personally inspected this property. The numbers are data driven, not firsthand. Questions about this property or this area? Reach out anytime. Ed Neuhaus, Neuhaus Realty Group

78945 Market Trends

$306,500 Median Sold Price ▼ 7.1% 6mo

$182/sqft Median $/SqFt ▼ 6% 6mo

106 days Avg Days on Market 3 days slower

34 homes Active Inventory 7.8 mo supply

93.1% Sale-to-List Ratio

26 Sales (6 months)

$177,950 Tax Assessed (2025)

Recently Sold Comparables

$197,000 adjusted 762 E Walnut ST, La Grange TX 78945 2bd / 1.0ba • 966 sqft • 1 mi Sold 4 months ago

$176,475 adjusted 443 S Madison ST, La Grange TX 78945 2bd / 1.0ba • 1,517 sqft • 0.8 mi Sold 2 months ago

$215,600 adjusted 927 E Walnut ST, La Grange TX 78945 3bd / 2.0ba • 2,124 sqft • 1.1 mi Sold 1 months ago

$198,000 adjusted 1014 S Madison ST, La Grange TX 78945 2bd / 2.0ba • 1,572 sqft • 1.1 mi Sold 4 months ago

$245,630 adjusted 355 N Monroe ST, La Grange TX 78945 3bd / 2.0ba • 1,600 sqft • 0.5 mi Sold 4 months ago

Currently on Market

$188,000 528 E Milam ST, La Grange TX 78945 2bd / 1.0ba • 983 sqft • 0.8 mi 500 days on market

$230,000 123 W Cedar ST, La Grange TX 78945 2bd / 1.0ba • 990 sqft • 0.9 mi 1 days on market

$169,000 833 E Camp ST, La Grange TX 78945 3bd / 1.0ba • 916 sqft • 0.8 mi 172 days on market

2 Beds

2 Baths 2 Full

978 Sq Ft

0.3523 Acres

1950 Built

1 Garage

About This Property

Quaint and full of character, this charming home sits on a desirable corner lot in town. Relax on the porch swing and enjoy the slower pace of small-town living. Thoughtfully renovated and updated, the home blends modern conveniences with its historic charm, preserving many of the original details that make it special.
Major updates include a 2-year-old roof, recently resealed and freshly painted stucco, and appliances that are all approximately 2 years old and covered by a transferable home warranty policy. The beautifully maintained original wood floors add warmth and timeless appeal throughout the home.
Outside, you'll find both a one-car garage and a covered carport for added convenience. A storage shed has been transformed into an adorable playhouse.
80 amp outlet in attic. adjoining lot also for sale if interested.
This home offers character, comfort, and the charm of small-town living all in one inviting package.

Features

Chandelier
Quartz Counters
Primary Bedroom on Main
Soaking Tub
Washer Hookup

Location

Map loading...

Schools

School District La Grange ISD

Elementary Hermes

Middle School La Grange

High School La Grange

Property Details

Property Type Residential

Construction Stucco

Roof Metal

Foundation Pillar/Post/Pier

Levels One

Flooring Wood

Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Electric

Heating Central

Exterior None

County Fayette

MLS # 8653118

Garage 1 spaces

Parking 3 spaces: Detached, Garage

Windows Double Pane Windows, Wood Frames

Lot, Outdoor & Utilities

Lot Features City Lot

Patio & Porch Covered, Front Porch

Fencing Back Yard

Other Structures Outbuilding, Shed(s)

Water Public

Sewer Public Sewer

Utilities Electricity Connected, Water Connected

HOA & Community

Community Features None

Tax Information

Annual Taxes (MLS) $2,444 (2025)

Assessed Value $177,950

Exemptions None

Listing History

MLS# 8653118 146 days

Oct 14, 2026	Off Market
May 21, 2026	Listed		$270,000

Frequently Asked Questions About 258 N Water ST, La Grange TX 78945

When was 258 N Water ST, La Grange TX 78945 built?

258 N Water ST, La Grange TX 78945 was built in 1950. It is stucco construction with 978 square feet on a 0.3523 acre lot.

How much does 258 N Water ST, La Grange TX 78945 cost?

258 N Water ST, La Grange TX 78945 is currently off market.

Similar Properties

$249,000 414 E Eblin ST, La Grange TX 78945 2 bd | 2 ba

$280,000 406 N Main ST, La Grange TX 78945 2 bd | 2 ba

$275,000 405 E Roitsch LN, La Grange TX 78945 3 bd | 2 ba

$294,500 420 JACKSON ST, La Grange TX 78945 3 bd | 2 ba

Browse More Properties

2-Bedroom Homes in La Grange Homes under $300K in La Grange All Homes for Sale in La Grange Homes in 78945 Homes in Fayette County Homes in La Grange ISD All 2-Bedroom Homes Homes for Rent Land for Sale

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

Your Name *

Email Address *

Phone Number *

Message *

Are you currently working with an agent? *

I'd like to schedule a tour

I am pre-qualified for financing

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.