4514 Caswell Ave, Austin TX 78751

Austin, TX 78751 | Ridgetop Annex

Ed's Opinion of Value

$555,748 Ed's Estimate: $699,578 $2,100,000
Lowest Comp Recommended List: $1,055,000 to $1,125,000 Highest Comp
The comparable sales data (7 recent transactions in RIDGETOP ANNEX) supports an estimated value of $699,578. The data suggests a list price between $1,055,000 and $1,125,000 would attract qualified buyers without leaving money on the table. Buyers shopping in RIDGETOP ANNEX right now would see this as a well positioned option among 7 comparable homes. Being built in 1919 (34 years older than comps) is factored into the value estimate. Lot size matters here: 0.30 acres versus 0.18 for the typical comp. Current inventory shows 7 comparable homes in RIDGETOP ANNEX; a buyer's market based on recent absorption. Prices in RIDGETOP ANNEX have fallen 6.7% over the last 6 months. A similar home at 809 E 45th 1/2 ST, Austin TX 78751 carries an adjusted comparable value of $555,748, providing a strong data point. This estimate draws on 7 comparable sales, offering a reliable picture of market value. That said, this is a data only estimate. A walkthrough could change the picture. Want a detailed analysis for a home you're considering? I'm happy to help. Ed Neuhaus
2 Beds
2 Baths 2 Full
1,592 Sq Ft
0.3024 Acres
1919 Built

About This Property

Built in 1919, this enchanting 2-bedroom, 2-bath Central Austin home offers 1,898 square feet of timeless character, lush outdoor spaces, and rare original details that will captivate your guests. From the moment you arrive, the limestone-accented front porch and the soothing sound of fountains create a welcoming, storybook entry. The front and side gardens lead to a serene koi pond with fountain, surrounded by lily pads and seasonal blooms, while a second goldfish pond with fountain anchors the private backyard oasis. A charming patio with a vintage barbecue pit sits perfectly between the two water features, creating an ideal space for outdoor dining and entertaining to the soundtrack of flowing water. With alley access and an oversized lot, there are ample future opportunities for expansion. Inside, original shiplap walls in both the front living room and kitchen add warmth and historic appeal, complemented by soaring 10’6” ceilings, wood floors throughout, and classic five-panel wood doors. The front living room features built-in corner curio shelves that highlight the home’s vintage charm, while the separate back living room offers a large bay window overlooking the expansive, tree-filled backyard, creating a peaceful and private retreat rarely found in the city. Storage is surprisingly generous for a home of this era, with two walk-in closets featuring high shelving, additional bedroom closets, and a charming kitchen built-in that serves as a functional pantry. A rear deck overlooks the back pond and garden, where roses, iris, and lush greenery bloom in the spring and summer. Ideally located in the heart of Central Austin near 45th & Red River and the Hyde Park area, this one-of-a-kind property blends historic charm, tranquil outdoor living, and exceptional character in a way that truly must be experienced. Schedule a showing today!

Features

  • Ceiling Fan(s)
  • High Ceilings
  • Laminate Counters
  • Crown Molding
  • Electric Dryer Hookup
  • Eat-in Kitchen
  • Multiple Living Areas
  • No Interior Steps
  • Primary Bedroom on Main
  • Soaking Tub
  • Walk-In Closet(s)
  • Washer Hookup

Location

Schools

School District Austin ISD
Elementary Lee
Middle School Kealing
High School McCallum

Property Details

Property Type Residential
Flooring No Carpet, Tile, Wood
Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air
Heating Central
Exterior See Remarks, Exterior Steps, Garden, Private Yard
County Travis
MLS # 4269989

Tax Information

Annual Taxes (MLS) $16,643 (2025)

Listing History

MLS# 4269989 9 days
Mar 13, 2026 Off Market
Mar 2, 2026 Pending
Feb 18, 2026 Listed $895,000

Frequently Asked Questions About 4514 Caswell Ave, Austin TX 78751

When was 4514 Caswell Ave, Austin TX 78751 built?

4514 Caswell Ave, Austin TX 78751 was built in 1919.

How much does 4514 Caswell Ave, Austin TX 78751 cost?

4514 Caswell Ave, Austin TX 78751 sold on March 13, 2026. Contact us for sale price details.

Similar Properties

Browse More Properties

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.