858 Rutherford, Fischer TX 78623

Fischer, TX 78623 | LEGEND@RANCHO DEL LAGO | Built by CAPITAL ENT MGMT & CONSUL

Off Market

French country inspired facade with stone siding, a shingled roof, a front lawn, and concrete driveway

Additional photos available to registered users

Ed's Opinion of Value

$453,984 Ed's Estimate: $624,345 $729,268

Lowest Comp Recommended List: $612,000 to $637,000 Highest Comp

After adjusting 3 comparable sales for differences in size, age, and features, this home's estimated value is $624,345. Pricing this home between $612,000 and $637,000 would put it in the competitive sweet spot for 78623. Buyers shopping in 78623 right now would see this as a well positioned option among 4 comparable homes. The larger floor plan (273 sqft compared to the average comp) is a meaningful differentiator in this price range. At 8 years newer than typical comps, the 2026 build date influences the valuation. There are currently 4 similar homes on the market in 78623, ranging from $530,000 to $650,000. Market data shows 78623 prices risen 11.5% over the last half year. The closest comparable sale, 281 Kellog, Fischer TX 78623 at an adjusted $657,690, is with a smaller floor plan. The comp data here (3 sales in 78623) gives us a clear read on this home's value. Important to note: this valuation is based on comparable sales data, not a physical inspection of the property. Curious about your home's value? Get a free estimate here. Ed Neuhaus

78623 Market Trends

$559,900 Median Sold Price ▲ 11.5% 6mo

$264/sqft Median $/SqFt ▲ 3.9% 6mo

92 days Avg Days on Market 38 days slower

14 homes Active Inventory 7.6 mo supply

97.8% Sale-to-List Ratio

11 Sales (6 months)

$97,650 Tax Assessed (2025)

Recently Sold Comparables

$657,690 adjusted 281 Kellog, Fischer TX 78623 3bd / 2.0ba • 2,049 sqft • 0.2 mi Sold 23 days ago

$729,268 adjusted 1061 Madrone RD, Fischer TX 78623 3bd / 2.0ba • 2,077 sqft • 0.5 mi Sold 5 months ago

$453,984 adjusted 541 Lasso LOOP, Canyon Lake TX 78133 4bd / 3.0ba • 2,121 sqft • 1.3 mi Sold 10 months ago

Currently on Market

$650,000 441 Eagle LN, Fischer TX 78623 4bd / 3.0ba • 2,548 sqft • 2.9 mi 19 days on market

$558,000 1761 Cottonwood RD, Fischer TX 78623 3bd / 2.0ba • 2,225 sqft • 0.7 mi 1 days on market

$530,000 624 JUNIPER CT, Fischer TX 78623 3bd / 2.0ba • 2,084 sqft • 1.9 mi 129 days on market

4 Beds

4 Baths 4 Full

2,355 Sq Ft

1.07 Acres

2026 Built

2 Garage

About This Property

View Virtual Tour

Set in the heart of Fischer, this single-story new construction home offers a layout that actually lives the way today's buyers want. 4 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, a dedicated office, set on over an acre, and in a gated community. Designed for gathering, hosting, and having space when you need it with soaring ceilings, natural light, an outdoor kitchen, and multiple en-suite bedrooms. Including a private in-law suite with an oversized walk-in shower, ideal for multigenerational living. The spaces flow seamlessly from kitchen to dining to living, anchored by custom cabinetry, gas cooking, and thoughtful finishes throughout. Expansive windows frame your private acreage and courtyard garden, while the long drive and generous parking create a true sense of arrival. Furnishings are also available for purchase, offering a turnkey opportunity if desired, and the builder is open to select custom modifications for buyers who want to personalize the space. Fischer is one of those places people discover and don't want to leave. Tucked between Canyon Lake, Wimberley, and New Braunfels, and within reach of both Austin and San Antonio, you're surrounded by rivers, wineries, and scenic drives. It's the Hill Country lifestyle without the crowds; quiet, natural, and steadily growing in demand.

Property Highlights

View Hill Country

Features

2 Primary Baths
2 Primary Suites
Ceiling Fan(s)
Beamed Ceilings
Vaulted Ceiling(s)
Chandelier
Quartz Counters
Dry Bar
Electric Dryer Hookup
Eat-in Kitchen
In-Law Floorplan
Kitchen Island
Natural Woodwork
No Interior Steps
Open Floorplan
Pantry
Primary Bedroom on Main
Recessed Lighting
Smart Thermostat
Soaking Tub
Study/Home Office
Walk-In Closet(s)
Washer Hookup

Location

Map loading...

Schools

School District Comal ISD

Elementary Rebecca Creek

Middle School Mountain Valley Middle

High School Canyon Lake

Property Details

Property Type Residential

Construction Board & Batten Siding, Stone, Stucco

Roof Shingle

Foundation Slab

Levels One

Flooring Tile, Vinyl, Wood

Cooling Ceiling Fan(s), Central Air, Electric, Exhaust Fan

Heating Electric, Fireplace(s), Forced Air

Fireplace Gas, Living Room, Masonry, Stone

Exterior Outdoor Grill, Private Yard, Restricted Access

County Comal

MLS # 2313514

Garage 2 spaces (Attached)

Parking 16 spaces: Attached, Driveway, Garage, Garage Door Opener, Oversized

Windows Double Pane Windows

Security Carbon Monoxide Detector(s)

Lot, Outdoor & Utilities

Lot Features Front Yard, Native Plants, Private, Private Maintained Road, Many Trees, Trees-Medium (20 Ft - 40 Ft)

Patio & Porch Front Porch, Patio, Porch, Rear Porch

Water Public

Sewer Aerobic Septic

Utilities Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Water Connected

HOA & Community

HOA Fee $250 /Annually

HOA Name THE LEGENDS@RANCHO DEL LAGO

HOA Includes Common Area Maintenance

Community Features Cluster Mailbox, Controlled Access, Gated

Tax Information

Annual Taxes (MLS) $1,465 (2025)

Assessed Value $97,650

Exemptions None

Listing History

MLS# 2313514 55 days

Apr 30, 2026	Off Market
Mar 20, 2026	Pending
Feb 21, 2026	Listed	$639,900

Frequently Asked Questions About 858 Rutherford, Fischer TX 78623

When was 858 Rutherford, Fischer TX 78623 built?

858 Rutherford, Fischer TX 78623 was built in 2026. It is board & batten siding, stone, stucco construction with 2,355 square feet on a 1.07 acre lot.

How much does 858 Rutherford, Fischer TX 78623 cost?

858 Rutherford, Fischer TX 78623 sold on April 30, 2026. Contact us for sale price details.

Similar Properties

$514,900 54 Persimmon Dr DR, Wimberley TX 78676 4 bd | 3 ba

$450,000 1742 Paradise PKWY, Canyon Lake TX 78133 4 bd | 5 ba

$450,000 72 Crazy Cross RD, Wimberley TX 78676 4 bd | 3 ba

$465,000 48 Whistling Wind LN, Wimberley TX 78676 4 bd | 3 ba

Browse More Properties

4-Bedroom Homes in Fischer Homes $500K-$750K in Fischer All Homes for Sale in Fischer Homes in 78623 Homes in Comal County Homes in Comal ISD All 4-Bedroom Homes Homes for Rent Land for Sale

Request Tour

Contact Agent

Interested in this property?

Get more information or schedule a tour

Your Name *

Email Address *

Phone Number *

Message *

Are you currently working with an agent? *

I'd like to schedule a tour

I am pre-qualified for financing

By submitting this form, you consent to receive communications from Neuhaus Realty Group via phone, email, or text regarding your property inquiry. You may opt out at any time. Your information will not be shared. See our Privacy Policy.